Q1.
The heights of the family members of Yaangba and Poovizhi are as follows: Yaangba's family: 169 cm, 173 cm, 155 cm, 165 cm, 160 cm, 164 cm. Poovizhi's family: 170 cm, 173 cm, 165 cm, 118 cm, 175 cm. Find the average height of each family. Can we say that Yaangba's family is taller than Poovizhi's family?
Answer
The averages say Yaangba's family is taller — but that conclusion is not safe, because one very short child pulls Poovizhi's average down.
Yaangba: 169 + 173 + 155 + 165 + 160 + 164 = 986 cm, 6 members
Average = 986 ÷ 6 ≈ 164.3 cm
Poovizhi: 170 + 173 + 165 + 118 + 175 = 801 cm, 5 members
Average = 801 ÷ 5 = 160.2 cm
Average = 986 ÷ 6 ≈ 164.3 cm
Poovizhi: 170 + 173 + 165 + 118 + 175 = 801 cm, 5 members
Average = 801 ÷ 5 = 160.2 cm
Now look at the actual heights instead of the averages.
| Yaangba's family (sorted) | 155 | 160 | 164 | 165 | 169 | 173 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Poovizhi's family (sorted) | 118 | 165 | 170 | 173 | 175 | — |
Why it happens: four of Poovizhi's five members are 165 cm or taller. In Yaangba's family only two members reach 165 cm. Poovizhi's average is lower only because of the 118 cm child — a value far below all the others. The average of 160.2 cm is shorter than 4 of the 5 people it is supposed to represent. When that happens, the average is not doing its job.
The strongest thing you can say: Poovizhi's family has the lower mean height, but the taller members. Saying "Yaangba's family is taller" would be reading the mean without looking at the data behind it.