Two mistakes. The correct answer is y = − 3/16.
- Both sides were divided by 3, but on the RHS only the 9 was divided — the 5y was left alone. It should have become 5y/3.
- Later, "2y + 4 = 3" was turned into 2y = 4 − 3 instead of 2y = 3 − 4.
Correct solution
3(7y + 4) = 9 + 5y
21y + 12 = 9 + 5y (open the bracket)
21y − 5y + 12 = 9 (subtract 5y from both sides)
16y + 12 = 9
16y = 9 − 12 = − 3
y = − 3 ÷ 16 = − 3/16
Check: LHS = 3(7 × (− 3/16) + 4) = 3(− 21/16 + 64/16) = 3 × 43/16 = 129/16
RHS = 9 + 5 × (− 3/16) = 144/16 − 15/16 = 129/16 ✓
Why it happens: the safest first move with a bracket is to open it, not to divide — dividing only helps when every term on the other side is divisible too. And when a term is removed from a side, its inverse appears on the other side: from 2y + 4 = 3 you get 2y = 3 − 4, which is − 1, not + 1.
Note: the answer is y = − 3/16. Opening the bracket first, as above, keeps every step in whole numbers until the final division.