How to do this well. This is a letter, so it must sound like one person writing to another — not like a textbook. But every complaint and every observation in it should come from something the chapter actually says.
What a good answer must contain
- Letter form: place and date at the top, a greeting, three or four short paragraphs, a closing.
- Daily life, concretely: the market, the fields, the river route, taxes, safety on the roads, whether the temple work continues — not just “there was war”.
- Why Kannauj in particular: it is the prize of the Tripartite Struggle because it commands the Ganga and the richest plain in north India.
- An opinion about the rulers, with a reason. That is what “your estimate of the rulers” asks for.
- Something addressed to Kanchipuram: your friend lives in a Pallava (later Chola) capital far to the south — a rich trading city that is not being fought over. The contrast is the point of the letter.
- Nothing invented that contradicts the chapter — the struggle ran through the 8th and 9th centuries “with fluctuating outcomes and no lasting victor”.
Kānyakubja, on the Ganga
The month of Śhrāvaṇa
Dear Ilango,
Your letter reached me only after four months, and the trader who carried it said the road from the Deccan was closed twice on the way. That will tell you most of what my life is like now.
We are on our third overlord in my lifetime. First the Pratīhāra army came from the west and everyone said the trouble was over. Then the Rāṣhṭrakūṭas came up from beyond the Narmada, and their elephants stood in our fields for a season. Now people say the Pālas are moving up the river again. My father says the flags on the fort change but the tax collector does not.
What has actually changed is this. Grain is dear, because carts do not risk the road when armies are near. My uncle, who is a boatman, does well in a quiet year and nothing in a year like this. The stonecutters were sent away in the middle of building the tank behind our street, and the pit is still open. On the other hand, the market has never had so many kinds of people in it — soldiers from Bengal, horse-dealers from the west, a scribe who writes in a Kannada hand.
You ask what I think of these kings. Honestly, I do not think any of them is wicked. They build temples, they feed Brahmins and Buddhist monks alike, they keep poets at court. But not one of them can hold this city, and each knows the other two will come back. So they take Kannauj, empty it, and leave. I have come to think that a ruler who stays is worth more than a ruler who conquers.
You are lucky in Kānchī. Your kings have to think about ships and merchants and temples, not about who is coming next year from three directions. Write to me about the new stone temples at Māmallapuram. I would like to hear about something being finished.
Your friend,
Devadatta