NCERT Solutions Poorvi Chapter 5 Feathered Friend — Let us explore

Book page 219 Updated on2026-09-05

Q1.
‘A canary in the coal mine’ is a popular phrase to describe early signs of potential danger. I Coal miners in places like Arunachal Pradesh used canary birds to detect the presence of carbon monoxide. Such gases are a potential risk to the life of the miners. These little birds are particularly sensitive to carbon monoxide and can prevent mining accidents.
Answer

This is the real practice behind the story's turning point. Here is what to find out and understand.

Why a canary and not a dog or a lamp? A bird's lungs are far more efficient than a mammal's. Air flows through them in one direction, through air sacs, so a bird takes in oxygen on the in-breath and the out-breath both. Its small body also has a very high metabolic rate. The result: a canary absorbs carbon monoxide several times faster than a man of the same weight, and it shows distress — swaying, then falling off the perch — long before a miner feels anything worse than a headache. That warning time is what saved lives.

Why carbon monoxide is so dangerous. It is colourless, odourless and slightly lighter than air, so no sense of ours detects it. It binds to haemoglobin roughly 200 times more readily than oxygen does, so the blood fills with a gas it cannot use. The victim grows slow, drowsy and confused — and confusion is the worst symptom of all, because it removes the ability to notice that anything is wrong. That is exactly the state Clarke's narrator is in: “My mind seemed to be very sluggish that morning.”

The Indian link. Coal in Arunachal Pradesh, and in the older fields of Jharkhand, West Bengal and Meghalaya, was mined in shafts where 'afterdamp' (mainly carbon monoxide and nitrogen) collected after a fire or blast. Caged canaries were carried down as living detectors. The practice was retired in favour of electronic gas detectors — in Britain formally in 1986 — and India's mines today use portable multi-gas monitors and continuous methane detectors under the Directorate General of Mines Safety.

What the phrase means now: ‘a canary in the coal mine' has become an idiom for any early, sensitive warning of a danger others cannot yet see. Ecologists call frogs a canary in the coal mine for wetland pollution, because their permeable skin registers contamination first; lichens are used the same way for air quality; coral bleaching is treated as an early signal of ocean warming.
Find out and discuss: (i) what a modern miner actually carries — a self-rescuer breathing device and a multi-gas detector; (ii) whether the canary was killed or revived — miners used a small cage with a door and an oxygen cylinder to bring the bird round, exactly as Sven's crew do with a face mask; (iii) one animal that acts as an early-warning system where you live.
Was this helpful? Report an error