FALSE.
The chapter is explicit: the hymns “were recited orally, not written”. They were “committed to memory through rigorous training and passed on orally with hardly any alterations” — for anything between 100 and 200 generations.
Book page 123 Updated on2026-09-05
FALSE.
The chapter is explicit: the hymns “were recited orally, not written”. They were “committed to memory through rigorous training and passed on orally with hardly any alterations” — for anything between 100 and 200 generations.
TRUE.
“They are the most ancient texts of India, and indeed among the most ancient in the world.” Experts have proposed dates for the Ṛig Veda — the oldest of the four — ranging from the 5th to the 2nd millennium BCE.
TRUE.
The hymn is translated in the chapter as: “The Existent [that is, the supreme reality] is one, but sages give it many names.” It is quoted immediately after the sentence that explains it: “The early rishis and rishikas saw those gods and goddesses as one, not separate beings.”
FALSE. The Vedas are very much older.
The chapter also makes the relationship clear in words: Buddhism was one of the schools of thought that “did not accept the authority of the Vedas” — which means the Vedas were already there, and already authoritative, when Buddhism appeared.
FALSE.
Jainism is “another important school of thought that became widespread at the same time, although its roots are said to be much more ancient”. The two are contemporaries, not parent and branch.
| Buddhism | Jainism | |
|---|---|---|
| Teacher | Siddhārtha Gautama, born at Lumbini | Vardhamāna, born near Vaiśhālī |
| Period | About two-and-a-half millenniums ago | Early 6th century BCE |
| Attainment | Enlightenment under a pipal tree at Bodh Gaya; became the Buddha | 'Infinite knowledge' after 12 years of ascetic discipline; became Mahāvīra |
| Distinctive teachings | Avidyā and attachment as the source of suffering; the Sangha | Anekāntavāda and aparigraha, alongside ahimsa |
TRUE.
Both are built on ahimsa, and in both it goes further than not striking a blow.
| Buddhism | Jainism |
|---|---|
| The Buddha taught “the idea of ahimsa, which is generally translated as ‘non-violence’, but originally means ‘non-hurting’ or ‘non-injuring’” | Mahāvīra: “All breathing, existing, living, sentient creatures should not be slain, nor treated with violence, nor abused, nor tormented, nor driven away” |
| “Conquering oneself is greater than conquering a thousand men on the battlefield a thousand times” | Insists on “the interconnectedness and interdependence of all creatures, from humans to invisible organisms” |
And in both, as the THINK ABOUT IT box on page 118 says, ahimsa “means much more than refraining from physical violence … It also means refraining from violence in thought.”
FALSE.
“Despite this multiplicity of deities, as with Hinduism, many tribal groups have a concept of a higher divinity or supreme being.” The chapter gives three examples, on pages 121 and 122.
| Supreme being | Worshipped by | What the chapter says |
|---|---|---|
| Donyipolo | Several tribes of Arunachal Pradesh | A combined form of the Sun and the Moon, “who later rose to the higher status of a supreme god” |
| Khandoba | Parts of central India | “This is also the case of the god Khandoba” |
| Singbonga | The Munda and Santhal, among others, in eastern India | “A supreme deity who created this whole world” |
“There are many more such examples,” the chapter adds. Tribal belief systems also include rich bodies of art, festivals, sacred landscapes and their own versions of the Mahābhārata and the Rāmāyaṇa. ‘Limited to spirits and minor deities’ is precisely the sort of biased 19th-century judgment that the chapter records as having been mostly abandoned.