Q1.
Consider the numbers represented by the following tokens: (a), (b), (c). We can see that all of them represent the number (– 2). Now, take 4 times each of these token sets. That is, place each set into the empty bag 4 times. What integer do we get as the final answer in each case? Do we get different answers because the sets look different, or the same answer because they all represent – 2?
Answer
All three give the same answer, –8. The sets look different, but they are worth the same.
First check what each set is worth.
| Set | Tokens shown | Value |
|---|---|---|
| (a) | 2 reds | –2 |
| (b) | 4 reds and 2 greens | –4 + 2 = –2 |
| (c) | 6 reds and 4 greens | –6 + 4 = –2 |
Now place each set into an empty bag 4 times.
(a) 4 × 2 reds = 8 reds → –8
(b) 4 × (4 reds + 2 greens) = 16 reds + 8 greens; cancel 8 zero pairs → 8 reds → –8
(c) 4 × (6 reds + 4 greens) = 24 reds + 16 greens; cancel 16 zero pairs → 8 reds → –8
(b) 4 × (4 reds + 2 greens) = 16 reds + 8 greens; cancel 8 zero pairs → 8 reds → –8
(c) 4 × (6 reds + 4 greens) = 24 reds + 16 greens; cancel 16 zero pairs → 8 reds → –8
Why it happens: sets (b) and (c) are just set (a) with extra zero pairs thrown in — one extra pair in (b), two in (c). Repeating a set 4 times repeats its zero pairs 4 times as well, and those cancel out at the end. So the answer depends only on the value of the set, never on how many tokens it happens to contain.
Tip: this is an important check on any model. If two pictures stand for the same number, they must behave identically in every calculation — otherwise the model would not be describing numbers at all.