Q1.
When constructing the perpendicular bisector, is it necessary to have the same radius for the arcs above and below XY? Explore this through construction, and then justify your answer. [Hint 1: Any point that is of the same distance from X and Y lies on the perpendicular bisector. Hint 2: We can draw the whole line if any two of its points are known.]
Answer
No, it is not necessary. The upper pair of arcs may use one radius and the lower pair a completely different radius. You still get the perpendicular bisector.
Upper arcs, radius r₁ ⇒ crossing point A with AX = AY = r₁
Lower arcs, radius r₂ ⇒ crossing point B with BX = BY = r₂
A is equidistant from X and Y ⇒ A is on the perpendicular bisector
B is equidistant from X and Y ⇒ B is on the perpendicular bisector
Two points determine a line ⇒ AB is the perpendicular bisector
Lower arcs, radius r₂ ⇒ crossing point B with BX = BY = r₂
A is equidistant from X and Y ⇒ A is on the perpendicular bisector
B is equidistant from X and Y ⇒ B is on the perpendicular bisector
Two points determine a line ⇒ AB is the perpendicular bisector
Why it happens: the proof never compared r₁ with r₂. Each point only had to be equally far from X and from Y — its own distance. Once A and B are both on the line, the ruler does the rest. What you must keep equal is the radius within each pair.
Check it yourself: draw the upper arcs with a small radius and the lower arcs with a much bigger one. The join AB still passes through the midpoint at a right angle — the picture just looks lopsided.